It doesn't contradict anything. I tried several times to explain this situation, maybe I should do a video.
1. Car runs fine, very well in fact, pulling hard, no misfire, nothing.
2. Suddenly engine stops (or die, or shuts off, I'm not sure how many different way I should be explaining this, needle is at 0 RPM)
3. Depressing the clutch restarts the engine which runs at 1,100 RPM, which its normal idling speed. This is normal since the clutch is depressed. If I let the car rolling with the engine off, it won't restart, only depressing the clutch will restart the engine. I can't try to restart with the key while car is in gear.
Hope it's clearer, it is not something easy to describe and I'm not trolling the forum.